Since 2017, more than a thousand Squishmallow characters have been released in the world of plush collectibles.
Their prices range from around $10 to more than $1,000, depending on the rarity, popularity, and overall condition of the Squishmallow.
But what is the most expensive Squishmallow ever sold?
We've asked some of our fellow Squishmallow collectors about it. Here's what we find out and the driving factors behind their prices.
Check All Available Squishmallows Here
Top 5 Most Expensive Squishmallows in the World
1. Jack the Black Cat
Sold For: approximately $1,000
Squad: Select Series
What Makes It Expensive: Jack the Black Cat is the 500th Squishmallow character, with only 500 pieces on its initial launch. Because of its special design, it has instantly become one of the most valuable and rarest Squishmallows ever.
From around $30 per piece, Jack the Black Cat can now be purchased for around $1,000 or more.
This Squishmallow has closed white eyes with a tiny pink mouth and white whiskers. It also has the number 500 on his left ear, making it the first limited edition Squishmallow sold through the official Kelly Toys website.
2. Avery the Duck
Sold For: approximately $500
Squad: Adventure, Farm Squads
What Makes It Expensive: Avery the Duck is one of the rarest Squishmallows, with only 75,000 pieces available in the market. But aside from that, this rare Squishmallow is also a part of the elite Farm Squad, consisting of only six Squishmallows, making Avery a highly sought-after rare collectible.
Avery is a mallard duck, small in stature but an extremely talented rugby team member. His entire family is always there to support him in his dream of becoming a coach someday, and they also love celebrating his games with popsicles.
This rare plush toy has a cocoa brown body, yellow beak, fluffy brown wings, and tan belly. However, another version of Avery has a darker belly and brown fur.
3. JSK the Cat
Sold For: approximately $1,000 to $5,000
Squad: Founders Exclusive
What Makes It Expensive: With just 250 pieces available, JSK the Cat has naturally become a highly coveted and one of the rarest Squishmallows ever made. What's more, the JSK name comes from the founder of Kelly Toys, Jonathan Kelly.
As a part of Founder's Edition, this Squishmallow can only be acquired through an exclusive Founder's Redemption Card. This Founder's Redemption Card is placed randomly in Squishmallows Trading Card Packs. So it's not just rare; it's also hard to have.
JSK the Cat has glittery blue and gold patches on a white body. As a calico cat, he has black eyes, whiskers, and an adorable pink mouth. The limited number of pieces and significance of this Squishmallow make it among the most expensive plush toys.
4. Stacy the Squid
Sold For: approximately $400
Squad: Adventure, Valentine Squad
What Makes It Expensive: Stacy the Squid is actually a common Squishmallow and not among the limited edition plushies, so how did she become one of the most expensive Squishmallows out there?
As her bio states, Stacy the Squid gained popularity online because of her "shy" personality. Shyness is one of the most common problems that many teens and young adults face nowadays, and many have been discussing the best strategies to help Stacy the Squid.
As a shy blue squid, Stacy is mostly home, by her closest friends or herself. She has a triangular head, black eyes, eight legs, a white belly, and a smiling face.
5. Warren Buffet & Charlie Munger
Sold For: approximately $500
Squad: Berkshire Hathaway Squad
What Makes It Expensive: Yes, you read that right! Our beloved Squishmallow plushies also feature real-life personalities such as Warren Buffet and Charlie Munger. But what makes these Squishmallows extra special? It's a pretty rare Squishmallow, and you can only buy it on-site during the Berkshire Hathaway Festival.
In this special edition Squishmallow, Warren Buffet, the famous financial guru, holds an ice cream bar while his right-hand man, Charlie Munger, holds a book of Benjamin Franklin's quotes.
These Squishmallows have a limited quantity, making them among the rarest Squishmallow plushies worldwide.
Since these Squishmallows come from an exclusive event, their value may vary greatly depending on the condition of the plushies.
What Makes A Squishmallow Expensive?
Limited Edition Releases
Limited edition releases are the bread and butter of collectibles like Squishmallows. When an ultra-rare Squishmallow is released at specific events, it ramps up the urgency and desire among collectors.
Hunting for rare limited releases has become popular since the COVID-19 pandemic [1]. The excitement around these limited releases boosts their value sky-high.
Like any other collector, securing a limited edition is like winning a plush jackpot for me. It's like having a piece of Squishmallow history since certain designs will never be available again in the future.
Character Popularity
Well, everyone has a favorite character, right? When a favorite character is turned into a Squishmallow, its popularity can drive the price up. Fans and collectors rush to get their hands on a soft version of their beloved character.
However, there are also popular Squishmallows from their original lineup, like Archie the Axolotl, Benny the Yeti, Brina the Bigfoot, and Connor the Cow [2]. These 24-inch giants make them popular among children and grown adults alike.
Kelly Toys incorporated adorable personalities into their stuffed toys, making them resonate with a lot of people and becoming a must-have comforting pal that everyone wants to cuddle.
So, if you think about it, it is just another usual case of the higher the demand, the more valuable an item becomes.
Condition & Authenticity
Guess what makes a Squishmallow not just cute but also super valuable? Yep, it's all about condition and authenticity. A bit rare Squishmallows in mint condition with original tags can significantly increase in value. Ensuring our plush pals aren't just adorable and genuine is crucial for collectors like us.
We also emphasize the importance of trusted sources and stores when looking for our next Squishmallow collectible. Here at Toynk, you can be sure that we only offer authentic and original products to our valued customers.
Market Trends
Like any collectible, most Squishmallows are subject to market trends. What's hot today might be even hotter tomorrow, so keeping an eye on the collector's market is crucial for serious collectors.
As mentioned, Squishmallows became more popular in 2020. People worldwide have been sharing their collections online on their social media accounts, which has helped their mental health during difficult times [3].
So, when a particular Squishmallow becomes a viral sensation, its price might skyrocket.
That's why knowing when to buy or sell can make all the difference in building a valuable collection. It's like being a stock trader, but way more fun because, well, Squishmallows!
Collecting Squishmallows as an Investment
Long-Term Value
Have you ever considered how those adorable Squishmallows could be more than just a cuddle buddy but also a savvy investment? It's true! Collectors are always on the lookout for those unique or hard-to-find models, and as they become harder to snag, their market value soars.
Some of the rarest Squishmallows have shown a remarkable increase in value. For instance, some early releases or ultra-rare Squishmallows that were once sold for a few bucks can now fetch hundreds, even thousands of dollars!
Cam the Cat (Easter Squad) was the very first Squishmallow. Although it does not command a high price, it's one of the most valuable collector's items at auction sites.
Other Squishmallows and collector's items you can watch out for are Mariah the Lamb (Baby Squad), who loves horchata and horseback riding, and Golden Han with a top hat and bow tie. Even Fania the Purple Owl sold at auction sites for around $3,000 a few years back.
Investment Tips
So now, you want to turn your Squishmallow collection into a serious investment? Great idea!
Here are some strategies to help you build a valuable collection: First, focus on rarity. Limited editions, discontinued models, or those tied to specific events are typically a good bet.
Keeping them in mint condition with original tags significantly adds to their value, so treat them with care—maybe even keep some in their original packaging if you can resist the urge to squish them!
Next, stay connected with the community, follow Squishmallow social media accounts, and participate in forums.
And lastly, diversify your collection. Don't just stick to a whole lineup of one squad. Having a variety of Squishmallows can protect you from losses if one particular type suddenly drops in popularity.
Risks & Considerations
Remember, the market can be unpredictable. Plus, ensuring authenticity is crucial, as fake Squishmallows can decrease in value and dampen the spirit of collecting.
The market has seen a rise in counterfeit Squishmallows, which can be almost identical to genuine ones. It not only makes it harder to maintain the value of your collection but can also be a trap for new collectors.
Always verify authenticity before purchasing, especially when dealing with rare or unusually cheap finds.
FAQs
What is the most bought Squishmallow?
Archie the Axolotl, Benny the Yeti, Brina the Bigfoot, and Connor the Cow are among the most bought Squishmallows. They even come in large sizes, perfect for cuddling during movie nights or as sleep companions.
Other best-selling Squishmallows include Willow the Tie Dye Pegasus, with rosy cheeks and a pink and purple body, and the lightly scented Blossom the Sheep.
Do people sell fake Squishmallows?
Unfortunately, yes. Some people sell fake Squishmallows. Like any popular product, counterfeits exist among these Squishy companions.
So, always verify authenticity. Only made purchases from trusted sites like Toynk and Kelly Toys website.
Squish 'Em!
A Squishmallow combines the features of a pillow and a stuffed animal. It is prized for its extra-soft, plush design, ideal for cuddling [4].
For a best-selling Squishmallow to start your plush toys collection, here is our adorable Squishmallows Disney 8-Inch Plush | Superhero Stitch. It's our favorite Stitch as a cuddly pillow wearing a superhero outfit.
Immerse yourself in the world of squishy plush toys with our wide variety of Squishmallow Collections.
References:
- https://www.nytimes.com/2021/03/16/style/squishmallows.html
- https://www.msn.com/en-us/lifestyle/lifestyle-buzz/most-popular-giant-squishmallows/ar-AA1loH9u
- https://www.bbc.co.uk/newsround/66173748.amp
- https://www.yahoo.com/lifestyle/why-squishmallows-trendy-now-look-160900859.html
