In the world of science fiction movies, two franchises standout from the crowd: Star Trek and Star Wars.
Star Trek is about deep space exploration with the Enterprise, while Star Wars is about epic battles between good guys and bad guys.
Both Star Trek and Star Wars movies are world-class, featuring cool characters and captivating science fantasy stories. But which is the best movie? Let's take a look at what makes Star Trek vs Stars special!
Star Wars & Star Trek Compared
When you compare Star Wars and Star Trek, you'll notice some big differences.
Star Trek is all about exploring space with the Starship Enterprise to find strange new worlds and promote peace.
Conversely, Star Wars is more about mystical elements, like the Force, and battles between good versus evil, like the Galactic Empire fighting the Rebel Alliance.
The Star Trek universe emphasizes moral dilemmas and scientific exploration, while the Star Wars galaxy leans toward action-packed narratives and mythic storytelling.
Both franchises have made significant impacts, offering unique perspectives within the science fiction genre.
Quick Look
|
Category |
Star Trek |
Star Wars |
|
Media Type |
Comic books, movies, television series, books, animated series, and video games |
Movies, books, TV series, comics, video games, feature films |
|
Genre |
Science fiction, drama, and fantasy |
Science fiction (Space opera and Military Sci-Fi) |
|
Weapons of Mass Destruction |
Phasers, shields, pulse, and torpedo weapon types |
Light sabers, blasters, cannons, and shields |
|
Fighters and Vehicles |
|
Various Spacecraft
Various Starfighters
|
|
Starships |
|
|
|
Main Characters |
The Original Series
The Next Generation
Deep Space Nine
Voyager
Enterprise
|
The Original Trilogy
|
Overview
Star Trek
The film Star Trek was originally a television series [1]. It follows an altruistic crew facing moral dilemmas, often contemporary social and political concerns.
Star Trek series tackles imperialism, war, racism, feminism, and human rights.
The central Star Trek characters, including Captain Kirk, Spock, Scotty, Uhura, and Pavel Chekov, represent a blend of humans and humanoid alien species.
Despite its television roots, Star Trek achieved widespread recognition following the success of its films in 2009 and 2013.
Star Wars
Star Wars films draw heavily on fantasy archetypes like princesses, knighthood, and battles between the light side and the dark side.
The Star Wars universe incorporates political science elements and historical references.
The climax of the Rebel Alliance's struggle against the oppressive empire mirrors events from the fall of the Roman Republic and the rise of an empire.
Due to Star Wars' continued success, its creator, George Lucas, whom Hayden Christensen, a Star Wars actor called a "visionary," even produced an animated series, "Clone Wars."
It is a part of the franchise, set mainly between the events of Episode II: Attack of the Clones (2002) and Episode III: Revenge of the Sith (2005).
More on Star Wars vs Star Trek
Creation
Star Trek was created by Gene Roddenberry, which runs from 1966 to the present. In 1964, Gene Roddenberry began drafting the concept proposal.
While he pitched it as a space Western – a "Wagon Train to the stars" – privately, he revealed to friends that he drew inspiration from Jonathan Swift's "Gulliver's Travels."
His utopian vision aimed to create Star Trek episodes that functioned on two levels: as thrilling adventures and as moral tales.
As mentioned, George Lucas created Star Wars, which runs from 1977 to the present. The concept does not prioritize realistic science; it is more about fantasy than strict science fiction.
Although the battle conflicts within the franchise were inspired by the Vietnam War, the central narrative is the "Force," an energy that permeates all life and can be wielded by Star Wars characters with unique abilities.
Production
The original series of Star Trek aired for three years in the late sixties after two pilots were made. Despite having dedicated fans, the show struggled with ratings and was eventually canceled.
There was only one cartoon series in the mid-70s [2] until the first Star Trek feature film revived the franchise in 1980.
This led to 11 more movies and several TV series until 2005. The 2009 and 2013 Star Trek reboot films by J.J. Abrams brought a fresh style and broad appeal.
In contrast, Star Wars is an original film in 1977, which became a global sensation. The Star Wars sequel trilogy happened followed every three years, with a prequel trilogy released 16 years later.
The sequel trilogy started from "Episode VII: The Force Awakens" (2015) to the "Episoce VIII: The Last Jedi" (2017) to the latest "Episode IX: The Rise of SkyWalker" (2019).
Check out our iconic Star Trek quotes here.
Reception
The reception of both franchises reflects the unique qualities of each franchise and their impact on popular culture.
Star Trek has cultivated a devoted following, which was praised for its optimistic vision of the future, diverse characters, and thought-provoking themes.
Despite initial struggles, it spawned multiple successful spinoffs and films.
In contrast, Star Wars burst onto the scene with universal acclaim, which captivates audiences with epic storytelling and iconic characters, like Darth Vader, Luke Skywalker, Boba Fett [3], and more.
While the original series garnered widespread praise, the prequel trilogy faced mixed reactions.
Both franchises continue to thrive with ongoing expansions and adaptations.
Star Trek is admired for its mind-blowing storytelling, while Star Wars is celebrated for its epic adventures, which leave incredible marks on fans and movie critics.
Social Elements
When envisioning the first season, Roddenberry aimed to inspire with a forward-thinking, liberal perspective, which reflects the cultural shifts of the 1960s.
While not openly discussed with television networks, Star Trek embodied Roddenberry's new hope for humanity's potential evolution, which emphasizes the importance of learning from past mistakes.
So, the first film of Star Trek has notably featured racially diverse characters to explore strange new worlds.
In comparison, Star Wars presents a classic tale of good (Luke Skywalker) versus bad (Darth Vader), with the Jedi representing the forces of good and the Sith embodying evil.
While it does not directly address specific social issues, it explores broader themes of light versus dark and authoritarianism versus democracy.
Even so, many have sought to draw parallels between the franchise and real-world historical and political contexts.
Legacy
Star Trek boasts a dedicated fanbase known as "Trekkies," who attend conventions worldwide, donning costumes and engaging in discussions about the show.
Some fans even immerse themselves in the show's fictional language, Klingon.
In fact, a Star Trek-themed attraction in Las Vegas entertained visitors for a decade, while museum exhibits featuring props from the show have toured globally.
What's even more notable is a NASA space shuttle named after the USS Enterprise [4], which is the crew's iconic ship.
On the other hand, the Star Wars franchise has evolved into a vast universe of spinoffs and merchandise, like books, video games, TV movies, comics, and cartoon series (Clone Wars).
Numerous animal species have been named after Star Wars characters, which highlights its cultural impact. References to Star Wars are commonplace in films and the media, showcasing its enduring influence.
FAQs
What is more realistic, Star Trek or Star Wars?
Star Trek is more realistic. It leans towards realism with a focus on science and technology, aiming for a plausible depiction of the future.
On the other hand, Star Wars prioritizes fantasy elements like the Force, making it less scientifically grounded.
Is Star Trek linked to Star Wars?
Star Trek and Star Wars aren't directly linked despite both being iconic sci-fi franchises. They have separate universes, personas, and storylines. However, they share similarities in themes and fanbase enthusiasm for the genre.
Final Thoughts
Each movie franchise has its strengths and appeal, and determining the best one is subjective. If asked, we would prefer Star Trek's scientific exploration, diplomacy, and optimistic vision of the future.
We like how it offers a thought-provoking examination of humanity's potential evolution. The franchise's focus is on the development of the show's protagonist and intellectual storytelling.
But if you prefer a more fantastical theme, Star Wars is a good pick. The epic space opera storytelling, iconic protagonists and villains, and timeless mythology are captivating.
If you're like us who prefers Star Trek's journey, explore Toynk's Star Trek merch collection to bring Starfleet Academy to life. Check out various toys and stuff inspired by Captain Kirk and the Alpha Quadrant!
References:
- https://www.britannica.com/biography/Gene-Roddenberry
- https://www.cnet.com/culture/entertainment/love-star-trek-lower-decks-give-the-70s-star-trek-animated-series-a-try/
- https://starwars.fandom.com/wiki/Boba_Fett
- https://www.nasa.gov/history/45-years-ago-space-shuttle-enterprise-makes-its-public-debut/
