What is the Rarest Squishmallow? (2024 Updated)

The Squishmallows phenomenon, brought to life by the creative minds at Kelly Toy, has taken the world by storm, captivating hearts with their irresistibly soft and huggable charms.

But what is the rarest Squishmallow?

We've spoken to dedicated Squishmalllow collectors, exchanged tales of discoveries, and deep-dived into the Squishmallows lore to uncover those elusive pieces that send collectors into a frenzy.

If you wish to check out the complete selection of available Squishmallows, kindly click the link below.

15 Rarest Squishmallows To Date 

1. Jack The Black Cat

Jack is a black cat, like Squishmallow from Easter Squad. He has white eyes, a darker belly, and white whiskers, which make him look like Hello Kitty.

We learned that this limited edition Squishmallow is a strong but silent type. Jack Black Cat Squishmallow loves cuddling and is always available to lend a helping hand. 

Estimated Value: Roughly $1,299.99

2. Avery The Duck

Attending Squishmallow swap meets was an incredible experience. I learned that Avery the Duck, with a green head and brown body, is one of the ultra-rare stuffed toys from the Farm Squads.

His belly is tan, and he has super soft brown wings. It also comes in a new Canadian exclusive collection.

Avery the Duck is on the rugby team, so don't underestimate him! He also has a family that loves to watch his games and bring popsicles to celebrate them.

Estimated Value: Roughly $499

3. Patty The Cow

Patty is one of the Squishmallow plush toys people adore most because of her pastel pink patches and the lavender-purple touches on her ear.

She's living with a Squishmallow family on a popular booth at the springtime farmer's market. Just imagine a whole family of squishy, plushy goodness!

Estimated Value: Roughly $290

Read: Best Place To Buy Squishmallows

4. Blossom The Sheep

Blossom is a rare plush toy that would make a perfect gift for a person who loves sheep.

If you're looking for an addition to your collection, Blossom is perfect for cuddling since he is less expensive than the other Squishmallows characters.

Estimated Value: Roughly $188

5. Gertrude The Goose

At a fan event, I met collectors of Gertrude, one of the rare Squishmallow toys that love adventure.

Although everyone knows her as the "bossy" type, she has a soft heart and loves helping Fania the Purple Owl, Calico Cat, and Stacy the Squid with brown fur and golden tentacles.

Gertrude is an adorable black-and-grey goose with a white belly and round black eyes. She is one of the Squishmallows that can only be bought in Canada.

6. Philippe The Frog

Philippe is a green frog and a rare plush toy with a white belly, green body, and a pale pink heart on his cheeks.

His black eyes are rimmed in white at the top of his head. We discovered that he is part of the Valentine baby squad Squishmallows, who enjoys playing hopscotch with his friends, especially Marco and Stacy the Squid Squishmallow.

But how rare is Gary the Giraffe Squishmallow?

7. Connor The Cow

Philippe is a green frog and a rare plush toy with a white belly, green body, and a pale pink heart on his cheeks.

His black eyes are rimmed in white at the top of his head. We discovered that he is part of the Valentine baby squad Squishmallows, who enjoys playing hopscotch with his friends, especially Marco and Stacy the Squid Squishmallow.

7. CONNOR THE COW

Connor belongs to rare Squishmallows that sellers often restock since many are attracted to him.

We noticed he had black and white patches with small, pale horns and black eyes.

He is an active Squishmallow athlete who loves riding his bike. This Squishmallow has been in California (which he considers the coolest place he has ever been to).

8. Celine The Hen

Celine is a light brown chicken and a rare Squishmallow with round black eyes and a light orange beak.

She is a great addition to your Squishmallow collection because she is considered a sweet and thoughtful Squishmallow.

Celine loves to hang out with her friends Fania the Purple Owl, Mallard Duck, and Stacy the Squid.

Check out what people think are the ugliest Squishmallows here. 

9. Lenora the Loon

Visiting thrift stores and garage sales led me to stumble upon vintage Squishmallows, Lenora the Loon- a black and grey Squishmallow exclusive to Canada.

She is an adorable aquatic bird with black wings, a grey body, a tan belly, and a white neck filled with vertical black stripes.

She is a part of the singer's Squishmallow family, but unfortunately, she can't sing.

Show her your love and support by including Leonora in your Squishmallow collection! Check out the cutest Squishmallows here. 

10. Santino The Platypus

The whole lineup of the rarest Squishmallows will not be complete without Santino the Platypus. He has a cocoa-brown body, a duck-like bill, and round eyes.

The manufacturers love to make Squishmallow toys with adorable personalities, and Santino is no exception.

He loves blueberry pancakes and spends most of his time playing soccer.

11. Willow The Tie Dye Pegasus

 

 

The Squishmallow craze has various character categories, like the Citrus or Fantasy squad, where Willo belongs.

She has a purple and pink tie-dye pattern on her body with rosy cheeks and a pink and lavender-colored tail.

She is one of the rarest Squishmallows, and she has tremendous energy. She loves going to her favorite fitness class with her friends!

12. Jackie The Purple Tulip

 

 

Some Squishmallows toys resemble Disney characters, and Jackie the Purple Tulip might be one of them.

We noticed that she gives off almost the same vibe as French Fry Floyd, except she is a tulip with dark purple petals up to the top of her head. 

Jackie loves shopping with her sisters and traveling together for a retro hunt! It is one of the rarest Squishmallows with large pale green leaves and a smiling mouth.

Read: What DISO Means In Squishmallow World

13. Daxxon The Purple Alien

 

 

Daxxon is part of rare alien Squishmallows embellished with purple, blue, and a white pattern of stars.

He has dark purple speckles, antennae, and a smiling face. This alien Squishmallow traveled far to join his fellow Squishmallows in world domination!

Read: Are There Fake Squishmallows?

14. Brigita The Snow Leopard

 

 

Squishmallow Brigita is a bit rare as she is one of the stuffed animals exclusive to Target (almost the same as the few reasons Mariah from the Baby Squad is rare as she is an Aldi store exclusive).

We like that she is covered with light green spots and a beige outline. This Squishmallow has a tiny pink mouth, loves bagels, and makes mornings more fun!

15. Louisa The Penguin

 

 

Louisa is a tie-dyed rainbow penguin with a large beak and round black eyes. She comes with fluffy wings and a small crown on her head.

Marketing her doesn't come so hard, as she is one of the Squishmallows who love to ski!

Read: Complete Squishmallows Master List

What Makes a Rare Squishmallow? 

Rarity Scale

On April 19, 2022, Squishmallows introduced a six-tier Rarity Scale, denoting limited edition Squishmallows with special tags [1], each with a fixed maximum production limit before their designs are retired:

• Rare: Silver tag, up to 75,000 units globally.

• Ultra Rare: Golden tag, up to 50,000 units globally.

• Special Edition: Holographic tag, up to 20,000 units, with exclusives like Tonya and Fiorello only in Amazon mystery boxes, and Jazmanian for Jazwares employees.

• Select Series: Black tag, exclusive to squishmallows.com, with 5,000-10,000 units; some select series are even more limited, available in sizes like 8" and 16", and some in Mystery Boxes or as 2-packs.

• Check-In Series: Purple tag, themed around special locations/events.

• Founder's Edition: Extremely limited, only available via a rare Founder's Redemption Card in Squishmallows Trading Card Packs.

FAQS

WHAT WAS THE FIRST SQUISHMALLOW?

We learned that Cam the Cat from the Easter Squad was the first Squishmallow released [2]. He loves going on adventures with his squad.

He is one of the most adorable Squishmallows, which is why most retailers always sell out for a limited time!

WHAT IS THE MOST SOUGHT AFTER SQUISHMALLOW?

Baby Yoda is one of the most sought-after (if not the most popular) Squishmallows in the market. He doesn't talk or move but has a powerful force of "snuggability." 

Baby Yoda has a green pastel color and big round eyes. Baby Yoda is a Squishmallow that is 100% adorable, lovable, and huggable.

Also, Original Hans, with his bow tie and top hat, Stacy Squid, and the Valentine squad are popular these days. 

But what's the biggest Squishmallow in the world?

HOW MUCH ARE SQUISHMALLOWS WORTH?

Most Squishmallows cost between $10 and $40, depending on their size and design [3].

There are a couple of Aldi grocery store-exclusive Squishmallows (like Jack the Black Cat- limited edition) during the second half of the pandemic. 

Some rare Squishmallows may cost from $500 to $2,000 in auction sites, depending on their relevance to customer demands.

HOW RARE IS THE RAREST PLUSH TOY SQUISHMALLOW?

Jack the Black Cat is a very rare plush toy. There are only 500 in circulation (limited edition plushies). It is the most expensive squishmallow created by Kelly Toys.

Also, we learned that Calico Cat is another Squishmallow that is hard to find today.

Where can I find rare Squishmallows?

You can find rare Squishmallows at specialty stores or through exclusive retail partners, on online marketplaces like Toynk, eBay, Mercari, Kelly Toys, or Etsy, and at collector meet-ups and trade shows.

Many teens and young adults sold their collections with a small affiliate commission, while others can be sold on TikTok and FB Marketplace.

Additionally, joining social media groups dedicated to trading and selling plush toys can help you discover unique finds and stay informed about new and rare releases.

WRAPPING UP! 

The 16" Jack The Black Cat is the rarest Squishmallow. We discovered that it is the first limited edition Squishmallow, with only 500 copies made. 

From Halloween Squishmallows to Christmas Squishmallows [4], these plushies the Kelly Toy Company created topped the Beanie Babies of the 90s!

Due to the comfort they provide and their bursting personality, some Squishmallows were easily sold out and were soon considered the "rare ones."

A common Squishmallow is typically affordable, but the most expensive Squishmallows sold reach up to a thousand dollars.

Make sure to check Toynk, as we sell authentic Squishmallows at affordable prices!